Whole, Hole, Who, Whose & How

The Silent W β€’ Relative pronouns β€’ Questions with who and how β€’ Non-fiction reading: Crater Lake National Park

1. The Silent W

Most WH words begin with a /w/ sound. But a small, important group begins with an /h/ sound. In these words, the W is silent.

WH = /w/ soundWH = /h/ sound (silent W)
what
where
when
why
which
white
who β€” sounds like "hoo"
whom β€” "hoom"
whose β€” "hooz"
whoever
whole β€” "hole"
wholly β€” "holy"
And HOW? How begins with a real H, and the OW at the end rhymes with now, cow, wow. Careful: who = /huː/ (hoo) and how = /haʊ/ (rhymes with cow). They are different words with different meanings!

Homophones: same sound, different spelling and meaning

Sounds the sameMeaningExample
whole complete, all of somethingI read the whole book in one day.
hole an empty space or openingThere's a hole in my sock.
whose possession (belongs to which person?)Whose phone is ringing?
who's who is / who hasWho's ready to start?
Pronunciation tip: Say whole and hole exactly the same way. Your listener knows which word you mean from the context: "I ate the whole cake" vs. "I fell in a hole."

2. Whole vs. Hole

WHOLE (adjective / noun) = complete, entire, all of it

She ate the whole sandwich. (= all of the sandwich)

I've lived in this city my whole life.

The whole class passed the test!

Grammar: whole vs. all β€” word order
the / my / this + whole + noun β†’ the whole day, my whole family, this whole week
all + the / my / this + noun β†’ all the day? No β€” we usually say all day, all my family, all this week.

βœ… We stayed the whole week.   βœ… We stayed all week.
❌ We stayed the all week.   ❌ We stayed whole the week.
Careful with uncountable nouns! Use all, not whole, with most uncountable nouns.
❌ I spent the whole money. β†’ βœ… I spent all the money.
❌ She drank the whole water. β†’ βœ… She drank all the water. (βœ… She drank the whole bottle of water.)

Plural: Whole + plural noun means "complete ones, not parts": The eruption destroyed whole forests.

Expressions with WHOLE

ExpressionMeaningExample
on the wholegenerally, in most waysOn the whole, I enjoyed the trip.
as a wholeall together, as one groupThe country as a whole needs more teachers.
the whole timeduring all of a periodHe talked the whole time!
a whole new…completely new / differentMoving here was a whole new experience.
whole milk / whole wheatnothing removed (full fat / all of the grain)I buy whole wheat bread.
wholesaleselling in large amounts, at lower pricesRestaurants buy food wholesale.

HOLE (noun) = an empty space, an opening

The dog dug a hole in the garden.

My jeans have a hole in the knee.

Word / ExpressionMeaning
potholea hole in the street (very common in Chicago in spring!)
sinkholea hole that suddenly opens in the ground
keyhole / buttonholethe hole for a key / for a button
black holea place in space where gravity pulls in everything, even light
a hole in onegolf: the ball goes in the hole with one hit
a hole-in-the-walla small, simple (often cheap and very good) restaurant or store
be in a hole / dig yourself into a holebe in a difficult situation, often with money
pick holes in (something)find small problems or mistakes in an idea

Quick Check 1

3. Who, Whom, Whose & Who's

A. WHO in questions: subject or object?

Subject question (no do/does/did)Object question (use do/does/did)
Who called you? β†’ Maria called me.Who did you call? β†’ I called Maria.
Who lives next door?Who do you live with?
Who saw the eruption?Who did the ranger help?
❌ Who did call you? (when who is the subject) β†’ βœ… Who called you?

B. WHOM (formal)

Whom is the object form. In everyday speech, most Americans use who. Use whom in formal writing and always after a preposition.

Everyday: Who did you invite?

Formal: Whom did you invite? / To whom should I send the letter?

C. WHOSE = possession

Question: Whose keys are these? β†’ They're Ahmed's.

Question: Whose is this? (= Who does this belong to?)

Relative clause: The woman whose car broke down called a tow truck.

Relative clause: Bashir has a brother-in-law whose car is very comfortable.

D. WHO'S = who is / who has

Who's your favorite singer? (= Who is)

Who's been to a national park? (= Who has been)

The test: Can you say "who is" or "who has"? β†’ write who's. If not β†’ write whose.
"___ coat is this?" β†’ "Who is coat"? No! β†’ Whose coat is this?

E. Relative clauses with WHO and WHOSE

TypeExampleNote
Defining (necessary information)A ranger is a person who protects a park.No commas. You can also use that.
Non-defining (extra information)William Steel, who first visited in 1885, loved the lake.Commas. Do NOT use that.
PossessiveThe Klamath people, whose ancestors saw the eruption, still tell the story.whose + noun

Whoever = any person who: Whoever finishes first can leave early.

Quick Check 2

4. How

A. HOW + adjective / adverb

QuestionAsks aboutExample answer
How deep / tall / high?size, measurementIt's 1,943 feet deep.
How old?ageIt's about 7,700 years old.
How far?distanceIt's about 80 miles from here.
How long?time / lengthIt took hundreds of years.
How often?frequencyTwice a week.
How much / How many?quantity (uncountable / countable)How much snow? How many visitors?
How well?ability, qualityShe speaks English very well.

B. Special expressions

ExpressionMeaningExample
How come…?Why…? (informal) β€” NO question word order!βœ… How come you are late? ❌ How come are you late?
How about…?a suggestion β€” + -ing or a nounHow about visiting in July? How about pizza?
How do you like…?asks for an opinionHow do you like your new job?
how to + verbthe way to do somethingI don't know how to swim.
How + adjective!exclamation (a little formal)How beautiful!

C. Indirect (embedded) questions

When a question is inside another sentence or question, use statement word order (subject + verb).

Direct questionIndirect question
How deep is the lake?Do you know how deep the lake is?
How did the hole fill with water?Can you explain how the hole filled with water?
Whose car is this?I wonder whose car this is.
Who lives there?Do you know who lives there? (subject question β€” no change)
❌ Do you know how deep is the lake? β†’ βœ… Do you know how deep the lake is?

Quick Check 3

5. More WH (and H) Sound-Alikes

In American English, these WH words sound the same as words without H:

WH wordSounds likeExamples
which witchWhich trail is easier? / The witch rode a broom.
whether weatherI don't know whether it will rain. / The weather is cold.
where wearWhere do you work? / What should I wear?
whine winePlease don't whine. (complain) / a glass of wine
whale waila blue whale / The baby began to wail. (cry loudly)
wholly holy / holeywholly = completely β€’ holy = sacred β€’ holey = full of holes

Silent H β€” the opposite problem!

In who and how we pronounce the H. But in a few common words, the H is silent:

hour = our β€” We waited for an hour. (Notice: an hour, not a hour)

honest β€” He's an honest man.

honor β€” It's an honor to meet you.

heir = air β€” the heir to the throne (the person who will receive something)

Remember: a hole, a house, a hotel β€” but an hour, an honest person. We choose a/an by the sound, not the letter.

6. Reading (Non-fiction): How a Whole Mountain Became a Hole

Before you read: key vocabulary

WordMeaning
volcano / erupt / eruptiona mountain that can explode with hot rock, gas, and ash / to explode / the explosion
ashthe gray powder that remains after something burns
collapseto fall down or fall in suddenly
calderaa very large hole that forms when a volcano collapses
geologista scientist who studies rocks and the history of the Earth
ancestorsfamily members who lived long before you
sacredholy; very important for religious or spiritual reasons
prospectora person who searches for gold or other valuable minerals
rimthe top edge of something round (a cup, a crater)
rangera person who works in and protects a national park
1,943 ft(592 m) deep β€” the deepest lake in the U.S.
7,700years since Mount Mazama collapsed
40+ ft(12+ m) of snow in an average year
1902became a national park

1Imagine a mountain about 12,000 feet (3,700 meters) tall. Now imagine that the whole top of that mountain disappears. This is not science fiction. It really happened in southern Oregon about 7,700 years ago, and the result is one of the most beautiful places in the United States: Crater Lake National Park.

2The mountain was a volcano. Today, scientists call it Mount Mazama. For about half a million years, it grew slowly as lava and ash piled up, layer after layer. Then, about 7,700 years ago, Mount Mazama erupted with enormous force. It threw so much ash into the sky that the ash landed in eight U.S. states and three Canadian provinces. Scientists believe it was the largest eruption in North America in hundreds of thousands of years.

3The eruption emptied so much rock from inside the volcano that nothing could hold the mountain up anymore. The top of Mount Mazama collapsed into itself. Where a whole mountain peak once stood, there was now a giant hole. Geologists have a special word for this kind of hole: a caldera.

4How did the hole become a lake? No rivers flow into Crater Lake, and no rivers flow out of it. Instead, rain and snow slowly filled the caldera over hundreds of years. Snow is very important here: the park gets more than 40 feet (12 meters) of snow in an average year. Today, the lake is 1,943 feet (592 meters) deep. That makes it the deepest lake in the whole United States. Because the water is so deep and so clean, the lake has an amazing, deep blue color.

5People lived in this area long before the eruption, and some of them saw it happen. Archaeologists have even found old sandals underneath the volcanic ash. The Klamath people, whose ancestors lived near Mount Mazama, still tell a story about the eruption. In the story, Llao, the spirit of the world below, fought Skell, the spirit of the sky above. At the end of their battle, Llao's mountain home fell, and rain filled the great hole. The Klamath name for the lake is Giiwas, and it is still a sacred place for them today.

6Thousands of years later, in 1853, a young gold prospector named John Wesley Hillman and his group came across the lake by accident. They were looking for gold, not for a lake! They had no idea how deep the water was, and for many years, few people outside the region knew about it.

7Then came William Gladstone Steel, a man who first visited the lake in 1885. He believed that the whole country should protect this special place. He wrote letters, gave speeches, and talked to anyone who would listen. He even carried fish to the lake, because no fish had ever lived there. Steel worked for seventeen years. Finally, in 1902, President Theodore Roosevelt signed a law that made Crater Lake a national park.

8The lake holds some surprises. Wizard Island, a small volcano that grew inside the caldera after the collapse, rises about 760 feet (230 meters) above the water. Near the shore, a small rock island looks like a ghost ship, so people named it Phantom Ship. And there is the "Old Man of the Lake," a tree trunk about 30 feet (9 meters) long that has floated upright in the water for more than 100 years. Nobody knows exactly how it stays standing up.

9Today, visitors can drive the 33-mile (53-kilometer) Rim Drive around the top of the caldera. Only one trail, the Cleetwood Cove Trail, goes down to the water. It's steep, so hikers who walk down must also be ready to walk back up! Swimmers often scream when they jump in, because the water is very cold, even in August.

10So, who should visit Crater Lake? Anyone whose heart loves mountains, history, or the color blue. And when you stand on the rim, remember: you are not just looking at a lake. You are looking at a hole where a whole mountain used to be.

Reading Comprehension

Grammar spotlight from the story:
β€’ Present perfect: Archaeologists have found old sandals. / The log has floated for more than 100 years.
β€’ Past perfect: No fish had ever lived there (before Steel brought them).
β€’ So … that: It threw so much ash into the sky that the ash landed in eight states.
β€’ Indirect question: Nobody knows exactly how it stays standing up.

7. Fix the Mistakes

Each sentence has one mistake. Find it, say the correct sentence, then click to check.

8. Dialogues: Be the Characters!

Work with a partner. Choose a role. Read the dialogue twice, then switch roles. For a challenge, click Hide to cover one person's lines and try to say them from memory β€” or change the details and make it your own.

Dialogue 1: At the Rim of Crater Lake

Ranger InΓ©s CalderΓ³n β€” a park ranger
Bashir Haidari β€” a first-time visitor

Dialogue 2: Back at Work on Monday

Marisol Ortega β€” Bashir's coworker
Bashir Haidari β€” back from his trip
Talk about it (after the dialogues):
  • Have you ever visited a national park or a famous natural place? How did you get there, and who did you go with?
  • Is there a place in your country with an old story about how it formed? Tell your partner the story.
  • Plan a trip with your partner: Who's driving? Whose car will you take? How long will you stay? How about camping?

9. Final Review

10. Your Turn: Speak or Write

  1. Who's the most interesting person you know? Why?
  2. Whose advice do you trust the most? Use a relative clause: "My aunt, who…, always tells me…"
  3. How long have you lived in this city? How has your life changed?
  4. Have you ever spent a whole day doing nothing? What happened?
  5. Describe a hole-in-the-wall restaurant you love. How did you find it?
  6. Write three indirect questions to ask a park ranger. (Example: "Could you tell me how cold the water is?")